Last month a report was issued regarding the BOP's on the ill-fated BP Macondo well. One commenter noted that BP was faulting the BOP's, and went on to liken BOP's to the "rear guard" in a war zone:
Itsy bitsy problem doomed BP's well
Those of us in the “Peak Oil Community” - as it is called - believe that Peak Oil will lead to a paradigm shift on the order of the Industrial Revolution. And we generally believe that Peak Oil is “upon us”. But with substantial challenges, come substantial opportunities …
Monday, April 18, 2011
Tuesday, December 14, 2010
Climate Change: A quote from Kenneth Deffeyes
"Warnings about climate change usually carry the implied message that any change is going to be disastrous. Only seventeen thousand years ago, New York City, Toronto, and Stockholm were buried under a mile of ice. (In a 4-billion-year history, 17,000 years is the day before yesterday.)"
Kenneth Deffeyes is Professor Emeritus in Geology, Princeton University, and author of Hubbert's Peak, Beyond Oil and When Oil Peaked.
Kenneth Deffeyes is Professor Emeritus in Geology, Princeton University, and author of Hubbert's Peak, Beyond Oil and When Oil Peaked.
Sunday, November 21, 2010
Wayne Keith unofficially breaks woodgas world speed record ...
Wayne Keith is a modern-day woodgas pioneer, a "deacon" of the woodgas community, if you will. Back in 2008, Wayne and crew won second place in the Escape from Berkeley alternate fuel race.
I had the pleasure of spending Friday, November 19, 2010 with Wayne Keith and family. Wayne first demonstrated his woodgas F150 experimental platform, as well as his woodgas Dakota "daily driver". Later we took the Dakota out for a spin around the backroads of St. Clair County, Alabama. Then, Wayne decided we should "stretch its legs" a little, so onto the Interstate we went. With a good head of woodgas and about 640 F coming into the headache rack heat exchanger, we topped out at about 85 MPH - but only because of traffic! We just couldn't get the cars out of the way on the stretch we were running. But since that is almost twice the current official record of 47 MPH, so we decided to call it a day. If it looks like we were going fast in the video, it's because we were! As you will see, Wayne startled me a little when he took the exit ramp like he had a little Earnhardt in him. No, we didn't roll the Dakota - I just quit videoing. What a fun and instructive day! Many thanks to Mr. Wayne and his family!
Wayne Keith's unofficial woodgas world speed record video:
More on Woodgas
Woodgas is quite simply a combination of H2 & CO, with a little CH4 or other heavies, plus the N2 that comes along for the ride from the air. Woodgas is produced when wood is pyrolyzed and the products are partially combusted and then reduced, forming the CO and H2.
The "technique" of producing woodgas has its roots dating to the early 1700's. Those early 1800's gas lights in Paris and the US were not from gas wells, but rather from producer gas - aka town gas or hydro gas - which is a cousin to woodgas, and is usually produced from coal.
Woodgas burns with a beautiful pink/purple flare, and is conducive to higher compression and advanced timing setups when used in existing internal combustion engines.
Video of the pre-startup flare from a Power Pallet, at the October 2010 All Power Labs workshop:
Woodgas falls into the partial solution category, with respect to our coming liquid fuels crisis. Woodgas burns cleaner than gasoline or diesel, but it is problematic in terms of operation, at least in terms of the expectations of today's drivers, who expect to be able to turn the key and drive without another thought as to what is going on in the engine. Operating a gasifier and the related systems currently requires mechanical experience and attention to detail. However, it may be possible to work out some of these issues. Also, the difficulties of dealing with a gasifier might be more palatable when it is your only choice for getting from point A to point B in your vehicle.
As an example of this line of reasoning, the Department of Energy thought enough of woodgas as an emergency fuel that in 1989 their FEMA arm sponsored the Oak Ridge National Laboratory to design a makeshift woodgas generator which could be constructed out of commonly available materials - in this case metal trash cans and a stainless salad collander, and a few other parts! The resulting design was problematic in terms of tar production (not desirable for engines) so it is shunned in woodgas circles. However, the fact that the DOE was interested in the technique as a potential, partial solution to a severe petroleum shortage - should be instructive. Gasifiers were used to power approximately one million cars, buses, trucks, trains, boats and generators during WWII, in Europe (Egloff 1943).
We have referred to woodgas in a few prior posts:
The coming liquid fuels crisis: the natural gas partial solution.
Oilpatch engineer replies to peak oil activist.
Last month I attended a wonderfully interesting three day workshop on gasification at Jim Mason's All Power Labs in Berkeley, California. Jim has unselfishly created an open source project to further the development of woodgas, and All Power Labs now has several products available for developers. The Gasifier Experimenters Kit, or GEK, is available for purchase, as is the Power Pallet - a pallet-sized package consisting of a GEK supplying a 10 KW Kubota genset with woodgas. During the workshop, with the assistance of Jim's friendly and motivated young staff, I was able to help construct a GEK and a Power Pallet. We also witnessed an extended run of the Power Pallet - it is amazing to watch ordinary woodchips be converted into electricity on a small scale! I intend to "write up" the workshop - the people, the experience and the education - but have not yet had a chance to put the notes in final form. In the meantime, details of the workshop and some pictures and videos can be found on All Power's website:
http://www.gekgasifier.com/
I had the pleasure of spending Friday, November 19, 2010 with Wayne Keith and family. Wayne first demonstrated his woodgas F150 experimental platform, as well as his woodgas Dakota "daily driver". Later we took the Dakota out for a spin around the backroads of St. Clair County, Alabama. Then, Wayne decided we should "stretch its legs" a little, so onto the Interstate we went. With a good head of woodgas and about 640 F coming into the headache rack heat exchanger, we topped out at about 85 MPH - but only because of traffic! We just couldn't get the cars out of the way on the stretch we were running. But since that is almost twice the current official record of 47 MPH, so we decided to call it a day. If it looks like we were going fast in the video, it's because we were! As you will see, Wayne startled me a little when he took the exit ramp like he had a little Earnhardt in him. No, we didn't roll the Dakota - I just quit videoing. What a fun and instructive day! Many thanks to Mr. Wayne and his family!
Wayne Keith's unofficial woodgas world speed record video:
More on Woodgas
Woodgas is quite simply a combination of H2 & CO, with a little CH4 or other heavies, plus the N2 that comes along for the ride from the air. Woodgas is produced when wood is pyrolyzed and the products are partially combusted and then reduced, forming the CO and H2.
The "technique" of producing woodgas has its roots dating to the early 1700's. Those early 1800's gas lights in Paris and the US were not from gas wells, but rather from producer gas - aka town gas or hydro gas - which is a cousin to woodgas, and is usually produced from coal.
Woodgas burns with a beautiful pink/purple flare, and is conducive to higher compression and advanced timing setups when used in existing internal combustion engines.
Video of the pre-startup flare from a Power Pallet, at the October 2010 All Power Labs workshop:
Woodgas falls into the partial solution category, with respect to our coming liquid fuels crisis. Woodgas burns cleaner than gasoline or diesel, but it is problematic in terms of operation, at least in terms of the expectations of today's drivers, who expect to be able to turn the key and drive without another thought as to what is going on in the engine. Operating a gasifier and the related systems currently requires mechanical experience and attention to detail. However, it may be possible to work out some of these issues. Also, the difficulties of dealing with a gasifier might be more palatable when it is your only choice for getting from point A to point B in your vehicle.
As an example of this line of reasoning, the Department of Energy thought enough of woodgas as an emergency fuel that in 1989 their FEMA arm sponsored the Oak Ridge National Laboratory to design a makeshift woodgas generator which could be constructed out of commonly available materials - in this case metal trash cans and a stainless salad collander, and a few other parts! The resulting design was problematic in terms of tar production (not desirable for engines) so it is shunned in woodgas circles. However, the fact that the DOE was interested in the technique as a potential, partial solution to a severe petroleum shortage - should be instructive. Gasifiers were used to power approximately one million cars, buses, trucks, trains, boats and generators during WWII, in Europe (Egloff 1943).
We have referred to woodgas in a few prior posts:
The coming liquid fuels crisis: the natural gas partial solution.
Oilpatch engineer replies to peak oil activist.
Last month I attended a wonderfully interesting three day workshop on gasification at Jim Mason's All Power Labs in Berkeley, California. Jim has unselfishly created an open source project to further the development of woodgas, and All Power Labs now has several products available for developers. The Gasifier Experimenters Kit, or GEK, is available for purchase, as is the Power Pallet - a pallet-sized package consisting of a GEK supplying a 10 KW Kubota genset with woodgas. During the workshop, with the assistance of Jim's friendly and motivated young staff, I was able to help construct a GEK and a Power Pallet. We also witnessed an extended run of the Power Pallet - it is amazing to watch ordinary woodchips be converted into electricity on a small scale! I intend to "write up" the workshop - the people, the experience and the education - but have not yet had a chance to put the notes in final form. In the meantime, details of the workshop and some pictures and videos can be found on All Power's website:
http://www.gekgasifier.com/
Labels:
GEK,
natural gas vehicles,
Peak Oil,
Wayne Keith,
woodgas
Friday, October 15, 2010
Dr. Hirsch's new book: The Impending World Energy Mess
Several folks have asked, "What's up with Peak Oil?".
Well, largely, the "coming energy mess" is masked by the "current economic mess". Namely, when you reduce growth in oil demand - as the world has done over the last several years - you don't notice the fact that the oil production rate really can't grow too much, anyway. At some point, though, the decline in oil production rate and/or the growth in demand ... meet. Or collide, we should say. When? Maybe 6 months, maybe a couple of years. It really depends on oil consumption, which in turn depends on the poor economic conditions that most of the world continues to experience. However, when demand does meet falling supply - look out. Another price shock will occur, then the economy will retract again, and demand will fall - a little, perhaps. But at some point we are down to bare bones - we've cut all discretionary demand, or at least all semi-comfortable, discretionary demand.
You may recall previous posts discussing Dr. Robert L. Hirsch, or the report which bears his name - the "Hirsch Report" - which was completed in 2005. This carefully written, non-sensational, 92 page pdf was entitled "Peaking of World Oil Production: Impacts, Mitigation, & Risk Managment". The Hirsch Report became semi-famous due to its quality, its content and also due to "who wrote it for whom". Namely, Dr. Hirsch, Dr. Bezdek and Mr. Wendling wrote the report for SAIC, who in turn was fulfilling a contract with the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE). (SAIC is a government contractor who some call "the biggest company you've never heard of". A few years ago SAIC went public; they have around 40,000 employees.) Initially the report was kept a "secret" to some extent. That is to say, initially the Hirsch Report could only be found on the website of a California high school! I would suspect that the DOE, etc. felt like it would send out shockwaves when folks read it. What they didn't understand was that since it wasn't a reality TV show, a lot of folks would never hear of it. Namely, a lot of folks just don't read. Further, there is a substantial amount of "thought inertia" out there - people have a hard time wrapping their minds around something so transformative. The Hirsch Report was ultimately placed on the DOE website, and it is currently linked on this blog (as is an interview with Dr. Hirsch, regarding the report).
Dr. Hirsch has been a speaker at the last several conferences held by the Association for Study of Peak Oil, or ASPO-USA. As an attendee at those conferences in 2007-2009, I listened intently to Dr. Hirsch's talks. I also had a few chances to chat with him. Last year I was able to ask him a question from the floor regarding the potential for natural gas vehicles to serve as a partial solution to the coming liquid fuels crisis (Peak Oil).
In observing his mannerisms over the last 3 years, and from his total focus on Peak Oil, it is my belief that the Hirsch Report had a profound effect on Dr. Hirsch himself. And realize that Dr. Hirsch has "done it all" - almost - in the energy business. He has a doctorate in engineering and physics, and has 40 years of experience, 15 patents and 50 technical publications. Dr. Hirsch was director of fusion research at the Atomic Energy Commission (AEC), Manager of Petroleum Exploratory Research at Exxon's Production Research, Manager of Exxon's synethetic fuels lab, VP and Manager for oil and gas research at ARCO, and then a senior staff member at RAND and SAIC.
The key takeaway from the Hirsch Report was that Peak Oil should be "prepared for", not "reacted to". Namely, the Hirsch Report posited that our nation could effectively deal with Peak Oil, given 20 years of intense transition efforts; that is, if we initiated efforts 20 years in advance of the peak. However, if only ten years of transition time are available, the Report predicted a painful transition process. And finally, according to the Report, if serious transitioning is not begun until after the Peak then "serious consequences" will result.
Dr. Hirsch, Dr. Bezdek and Mr. Wendling have now written The Impending World Energy Mess, which was released around October 1, 2010.
The book includes a forward by Dr. James R. Schlesinger, the first U. S. Secretary of Energy, former Chairman of the Atomic Energy Commission, former Director of the Central Intelligence Agency and former Secretary of Defense.
The book doesn't plow a lot of new ground for those of us that have been familiar with Peak Oil. However, the book is an important "signpost" or "threshold" - the first book regarding Peak Oil from a very sophisticated, highly respected, former government analyst. The book is well-written, side-barred and highlighted. It is easy to read, and easy to refer to. The book also goes into substantial detail on various "partial solutions", as well as those which have been "ruled out". Included are excellent discussions on fusion, biomass, ethanol, and coal and gas-to-liquids.
Some of the most valuable content is that of the discussion of possible rationing plans - for gasoline and diesel. Not voluntary rationing - mandatory rationing. Given the circles in which the authors travel, I would imagine that what they have written is similar to what the government might invoke. Some might wonder why a Prius might be better to have than a Corolla, given that the economics never seem to catch up at say, $3 gasoline. However, in addition to being a means to contribute to conservation, an excellent piece of overall fuel efficiency engineering and a highly drivable vehicle, the Prius will go a lot further on a gallon of gas than will a Corolla. This may equalize the economics, somewhat, when it means another ten trips to the grocery store or school, or perhaps an additional 100 miles per ten gallon tankful, vis-a-vis the Corolla.
The Impending World Energy Mess should create additional awareness of Peak Oil - we will see what the reaction/consequences are.
Shown below are a two interviews with Dr. Hirsch, regarding the book, and a book review:
Steve Andrews of ASPO-USA interviews Dr. Hirsch regarding his book
Matthew Auzanneau interviews Dr. Hirsch regarding his book
Tom Whipple reviews Dr. Hirsch's book
Well, largely, the "coming energy mess" is masked by the "current economic mess". Namely, when you reduce growth in oil demand - as the world has done over the last several years - you don't notice the fact that the oil production rate really can't grow too much, anyway. At some point, though, the decline in oil production rate and/or the growth in demand ... meet. Or collide, we should say. When? Maybe 6 months, maybe a couple of years. It really depends on oil consumption, which in turn depends on the poor economic conditions that most of the world continues to experience. However, when demand does meet falling supply - look out. Another price shock will occur, then the economy will retract again, and demand will fall - a little, perhaps. But at some point we are down to bare bones - we've cut all discretionary demand, or at least all semi-comfortable, discretionary demand.
You may recall previous posts discussing Dr. Robert L. Hirsch, or the report which bears his name - the "Hirsch Report" - which was completed in 2005. This carefully written, non-sensational, 92 page pdf was entitled "Peaking of World Oil Production: Impacts, Mitigation, & Risk Managment". The Hirsch Report became semi-famous due to its quality, its content and also due to "who wrote it for whom". Namely, Dr. Hirsch, Dr. Bezdek and Mr. Wendling wrote the report for SAIC, who in turn was fulfilling a contract with the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE). (SAIC is a government contractor who some call "the biggest company you've never heard of". A few years ago SAIC went public; they have around 40,000 employees.) Initially the report was kept a "secret" to some extent. That is to say, initially the Hirsch Report could only be found on the website of a California high school! I would suspect that the DOE, etc. felt like it would send out shockwaves when folks read it. What they didn't understand was that since it wasn't a reality TV show, a lot of folks would never hear of it. Namely, a lot of folks just don't read. Further, there is a substantial amount of "thought inertia" out there - people have a hard time wrapping their minds around something so transformative. The Hirsch Report was ultimately placed on the DOE website, and it is currently linked on this blog (as is an interview with Dr. Hirsch, regarding the report).
Dr. Hirsch has been a speaker at the last several conferences held by the Association for Study of Peak Oil, or ASPO-USA. As an attendee at those conferences in 2007-2009, I listened intently to Dr. Hirsch's talks. I also had a few chances to chat with him. Last year I was able to ask him a question from the floor regarding the potential for natural gas vehicles to serve as a partial solution to the coming liquid fuels crisis (Peak Oil).
In observing his mannerisms over the last 3 years, and from his total focus on Peak Oil, it is my belief that the Hirsch Report had a profound effect on Dr. Hirsch himself. And realize that Dr. Hirsch has "done it all" - almost - in the energy business. He has a doctorate in engineering and physics, and has 40 years of experience, 15 patents and 50 technical publications. Dr. Hirsch was director of fusion research at the Atomic Energy Commission (AEC), Manager of Petroleum Exploratory Research at Exxon's Production Research, Manager of Exxon's synethetic fuels lab, VP and Manager for oil and gas research at ARCO, and then a senior staff member at RAND and SAIC.
The key takeaway from the Hirsch Report was that Peak Oil should be "prepared for", not "reacted to". Namely, the Hirsch Report posited that our nation could effectively deal with Peak Oil, given 20 years of intense transition efforts; that is, if we initiated efforts 20 years in advance of the peak. However, if only ten years of transition time are available, the Report predicted a painful transition process. And finally, according to the Report, if serious transitioning is not begun until after the Peak then "serious consequences" will result.
Dr. Hirsch, Dr. Bezdek and Mr. Wendling have now written The Impending World Energy Mess, which was released around October 1, 2010.
The book includes a forward by Dr. James R. Schlesinger, the first U. S. Secretary of Energy, former Chairman of the Atomic Energy Commission, former Director of the Central Intelligence Agency and former Secretary of Defense.
The book doesn't plow a lot of new ground for those of us that have been familiar with Peak Oil. However, the book is an important "signpost" or "threshold" - the first book regarding Peak Oil from a very sophisticated, highly respected, former government analyst. The book is well-written, side-barred and highlighted. It is easy to read, and easy to refer to. The book also goes into substantial detail on various "partial solutions", as well as those which have been "ruled out". Included are excellent discussions on fusion, biomass, ethanol, and coal and gas-to-liquids.
Some of the most valuable content is that of the discussion of possible rationing plans - for gasoline and diesel. Not voluntary rationing - mandatory rationing. Given the circles in which the authors travel, I would imagine that what they have written is similar to what the government might invoke. Some might wonder why a Prius might be better to have than a Corolla, given that the economics never seem to catch up at say, $3 gasoline. However, in addition to being a means to contribute to conservation, an excellent piece of overall fuel efficiency engineering and a highly drivable vehicle, the Prius will go a lot further on a gallon of gas than will a Corolla. This may equalize the economics, somewhat, when it means another ten trips to the grocery store or school, or perhaps an additional 100 miles per ten gallon tankful, vis-a-vis the Corolla.
The Impending World Energy Mess should create additional awareness of Peak Oil - we will see what the reaction/consequences are.
Shown below are a two interviews with Dr. Hirsch, regarding the book, and a book review:
Steve Andrews of ASPO-USA interviews Dr. Hirsch regarding his book
Matthew Auzanneau interviews Dr. Hirsch regarding his book
Tom Whipple reviews Dr. Hirsch's book
Sunday, July 25, 2010
Blowout Prevention Act of 2010
According to the Wall Street Journal (7/22/2010, Son of Cap and Tax) last week the House Energy Committee unanimously (Republicans and Democrats) approved the Blowout Prevention Act of 2010 (link to Discussion Draft):
http://energycommerce.house.gov/documents/20100625/Discussion.Draft.Blowout.Prevention.Act.2010.pdf
As always, the devil is in the details. This Act will not only apply to deepwater and Federal fee, but will also apply to any onshore drilling operation - on any property, public or private - that the Federal officials determine could "in the event of a blowout, ... lead to substantial harm to public health or safety or to the environment."
While this may not sound unreasonable, the problem is that under this language the Federal bureaucracy is expanded and can potentially control any and perhaps all drilling operations. Accordingly, drilling could come to a standstill until the Feds promulgate "how to decide" and "who gets to decide", set up more agencies, etc. Once they determine what applies - and what the process for determination and approval is - the typical inertia of the Federal government could throw a wrench in permitting wells. There is a provision to allow delegation of the task to the states, where said states are capable of making the determination and managing the risk. This would be the best option for all, as opposed to setting up additional, overlapping Federal bureaucracy.
Additionally, wells for which the Act applies ("High-Risk Wells", subjectively defined in this Act) will require "two sets of shear rams and two sets of casing shear rams". It would not be hard to imagine that only a few, if any, current land-based drilling rigs have enough substructure space for such aBOP stack. So, if no such rigs exist, many deep wells (and even some relatively shallow ones) could be delayed indefinitely until/unless new, very expensive drilling rigs are built - depending on the interpretations of the Federal government.
http://energycommerce.house.gov/documents/20100625/Discussion.Draft.Blowout.Prevention.Act.2010.pdf
As always, the devil is in the details. This Act will not only apply to deepwater and Federal fee, but will also apply to any onshore drilling operation - on any property, public or private - that the Federal officials determine could "in the event of a blowout, ... lead to substantial harm to public health or safety or to the environment."
While this may not sound unreasonable, the problem is that under this language the Federal bureaucracy is expanded and can potentially control any and perhaps all drilling operations. Accordingly, drilling could come to a standstill until the Feds promulgate "how to decide" and "who gets to decide", set up more agencies, etc. Once they determine what applies - and what the process for determination and approval is - the typical inertia of the Federal government could throw a wrench in permitting wells. There is a provision to allow delegation of the task to the states, where said states are capable of making the determination and managing the risk. This would be the best option for all, as opposed to setting up additional, overlapping Federal bureaucracy.
Additionally, wells for which the Act applies ("High-Risk Wells", subjectively defined in this Act) will require "two sets of shear rams and two sets of casing shear rams". It would not be hard to imagine that only a few, if any, current land-based drilling rigs have enough substructure space for such a
Oilpatch engineer replies to peak oil activist
As posted on Energy Bulletin's site:
So, to get started - to find that common ground that Bart referred to in order to solve these problems - we need to start by avoiding the use of stereotypes. I don’t know Mr. Lundgren, and any stereotype I might choose for him would be an unfair, simplistic description for someone who is likely one of those folks who “proudly defies classification”. Being stereotyped really didn’t upset me; in fact, it reminded me, once again, how stereotypes often prevent us from building bridges and making progress on really important issues.
On Climate Change
I believe it was Dr. Hirsch, at one of the ASPO-USA conferences, who said that yes, climate change may be a problem, but the problem of Peak Oil is much more pressing, and will impact the world sooner than the problems of climate change. Further, the solutions for Peak Oil - and Peak Oil itself - will tend to reduce carbon emissions. Even if we ramp up our exploration efforts (which is essential), my belief is that - based on the work of Dr. Campbell and Dr. Hirsch - we will be using 3 – 5 % less oil each year, within a few years. This reduction in oil production/consumption will add up in a hurry (one of the key points of the Hirsch Report timeline).
Without opening the debate on whether man has caused or exacerbated climate change, it should be pointed out that 13,000 years ago, sea levels were about 250 feet lower. In other words, sea level has risen about 250 feet in 13,000 years. Further, about 79 million years prior to that, where I now sit was covered with about 150 feet of seawater. The Earth Chamber of Commerce website should include the bullet point: “climate subject to significant, periodic change”.
On Lifestyle Change
As I pointed out in the article, I believe that we should be “transitioning how we live, work and eat.” I don’t know how else to suggest lifestyle change. One of my near term goals is to work more towards providing good examples and paths for these “changes”. The good news is that although we have a long way to go, progress is being made.
On Current Dependence on Fossil Fuels
If we’re not addicted to fossil fuels, if they are not ingrained in everything – then Peak Oil is a non-issue.
We had the oil, we used the oil. It allowed quantum leaps in quality of life, life span, medicine and materials, among other things. With the benefit of 20/20 hindsight we can say we “wasted” a lot of oil, as well, depending on your frame of reference. The abundance of concentrated energy led to a dependence on same – it would be hard to debate otherwise. This abundance also led to some lifestyles – like suburbia – which were unsustainable. I don’t think anyone planned suburbia in a malicious fashion, nor is anyone even culpable by omission. Suburbia is just a result of using what we had. Currently, suburban sprawl is working its way towards the history books. Rather than wasting time beating ourselves up as to “how stupid we were”, we need to look forward, not backward. We need to figure out how to wisely use what we have to transition to the next lifestyles, the next economy. To get there, we need oil, gas and coal. So take a roughneck or a coal miner to lunch!
So, you ride a bike or walk? Sure, you use far less energy. But the bike is made of coal (smelted aluminum and iron) and oil (tires, seat, plastic), then it is painted with oil. It’s a Gary Fisher, you say? OK, clear-coated with oil, or anodized with coal. Your Nikes or Chacos are pure oil, plus some coal (Chinese electricity) toted over on a smoky, Bunker No. 6-burning container ship. Your PV system (and mine): oil (plastic) and coal (aluminum), in combination with coal (electricity to make the smelt the silicon, refine the cadmium and tellurium), plus some more coal (electricity) to run the plant. And those coal plants which make the electricity to make these “clean energy” solar cells (of yours and mine) are over in China, where they can’t be protested. They’re out of sight and out of mind, unless you’re Chinese and breathing the effluent of a plant which no doubt has far fewer scrubbers and precipitators than those required in the US.
The point is, currently and for the foreseeable future, we are all dependent on these extractive industries, and fossil fuels. So we all need to work together - and not demonize industries that we need - even as we transition to lifestyles with far lower energy usage and local energy production using alternatives.
On the Hirsh Report
I have been a follower of the Hirsch Report since 2004-2005 when it was located exclusively on the “Hilltop Lancers” high school website (I think I found it there due to the Energy Bulletin). I have been familiar with Hubbert’s Peak and a student of oil supply since the mid-1980’s. Even so, when I read the Hirsch Report for the first time - saw who wrote it, who commissioned it - it really sent a chill up my spine. I have had the pleasure of hearing Dr. Hirsch on several occasions – both times at ASPO-USA conferences – in Sacramento and Denver. Observing how his report has no doubt affected him, personally – sent another chill up my spine.
In this most recent posting, I paraphrased the time periods stated in the Hirsch Report, for simplicity. Frankly, yesterday’s gone, and it’s what we do today and tomorrow that counts. None of us knows the timing exactly. We do know that we best “get going”. Recently I have tried to “tone it down” a bit: I think the “imminent crisis” theme turns off certain groups of folks. Regardless, there are lots of writers already making the “crisis case”, so it would seem that another approach might reach incremental people. Namely, it’s easy, fun and fashionable to use less oil, and less energy in general. Anyway, a long-winded explanation for why I simplified the Hirsch Report conclusions.
For the record, I have published the Hirsch Report conclusions in detail, previously, in “The coming liquid fuels crisis: The natural gas (partial) solution”, as excerpted here:
I am against it. I have read all the books and blogs, from Jared Diamond to the Olduvai Theory to Jay Hanson, and on. The Rainwater Prophecy is linked on the blog. But so long as we are not yet “collapsed”, there is the potential for the great ingenuity of the people of our country and the world to ultimately prevail. I won’t give up hope or effort, and I trust that a lot of others won’t, either. I’m just not a fatalist; I believe we can make a difference. That doesn’t mean, of course, that we won’t have “severe consequences” to deal with.
The reality is - although there is a long ways to go, there is also “a lot going on”, much of it over the last five years. None of these steps, taken alone, will “save the world”. Symbolically, however, they represent changes in behavior and belief that if continued and extended, will have meaningful effects:
One of the pleasures of editing Energy Bulletin is publishing a wide variety of views. Sometimes they clash, and the results can be fascinating.Thanks for the comments, Mr. Lundgren. ... There is a lot of emotion out there. If we could bottle it up, use it for positive purposes, we’d have the “free energy” Tesla evidently took to his grave!
This time, the clash is between two regular contributors, oilpatch engineer Martin B. Payne and long-time peak oil activist and writer, Jan Lundberg, publisher of Culture Change. On July 4, we published Martin's article "Take this opportunity to unite our country, not divide it". Jan wrote some comments to me (as EB editor) and I asked his permission to post them at the bottom of that article. They are as follows:
I see the author is basically an oil man and in good standing with API. But just because such a person acknowledges peak oil, does that make his statements worthy when they have no ecological sense or concern for the climate? He's also close-minded to life-style change.In the following article, Martin Payne steps back and gives full voice to "the enlightened fossil fuel professional."
I know that it's foolish to believe people cannot go car-free overnight. Also, if fossil fuels are "part of what we are," then we deserve to drown in a BP blowout. The blurb you put on the home page for the article looked intriguing, although the title of his piece obviously pegged him as someone not subscribing to collapse likelihood. He doesn't get Hirsch. Hirsch did not say we have 20 years for a transition (Payne says "during the transition"). Hirsch said that we had 20 years before peak.
Interestingly, the dividing line between activist and oilman is not as sharp as first appears. Before turning to activism, Jan worked for many years in the family business, Lundberg Survey, which reports on the US petroleum marketing industry.
And as you will read below, oilman Payne betrays shocking patches of green.
(The iniitial article is posted here.)
-BA
So, to get started - to find that common ground that Bart referred to in order to solve these problems - we need to start by avoiding the use of stereotypes. I don’t know Mr. Lundgren, and any stereotype I might choose for him would be an unfair, simplistic description for someone who is likely one of those folks who “proudly defies classification”. Being stereotyped really didn’t upset me; in fact, it reminded me, once again, how stereotypes often prevent us from building bridges and making progress on really important issues.
On Climate Change
I believe it was Dr. Hirsch, at one of the ASPO-USA conferences, who said that yes, climate change may be a problem, but the problem of Peak Oil is much more pressing, and will impact the world sooner than the problems of climate change. Further, the solutions for Peak Oil - and Peak Oil itself - will tend to reduce carbon emissions. Even if we ramp up our exploration efforts (which is essential), my belief is that - based on the work of Dr. Campbell and Dr. Hirsch - we will be using 3 – 5 % less oil each year, within a few years. This reduction in oil production/consumption will add up in a hurry (one of the key points of the Hirsch Report timeline).
Without opening the debate on whether man has caused or exacerbated climate change, it should be pointed out that 13,000 years ago, sea levels were about 250 feet lower. In other words, sea level has risen about 250 feet in 13,000 years. Further, about 79 million years prior to that, where I now sit was covered with about 150 feet of seawater. The Earth Chamber of Commerce website should include the bullet point: “climate subject to significant, periodic change”.
On Lifestyle Change
As I pointed out in the article, I believe that we should be “transitioning how we live, work and eat.” I don’t know how else to suggest lifestyle change. One of my near term goals is to work more towards providing good examples and paths for these “changes”. The good news is that although we have a long way to go, progress is being made.
On Current Dependence on Fossil Fuels
If we’re not addicted to fossil fuels, if they are not ingrained in everything – then Peak Oil is a non-issue.
We had the oil, we used the oil. It allowed quantum leaps in quality of life, life span, medicine and materials, among other things. With the benefit of 20/20 hindsight we can say we “wasted” a lot of oil, as well, depending on your frame of reference. The abundance of concentrated energy led to a dependence on same – it would be hard to debate otherwise. This abundance also led to some lifestyles – like suburbia – which were unsustainable. I don’t think anyone planned suburbia in a malicious fashion, nor is anyone even culpable by omission. Suburbia is just a result of using what we had. Currently, suburban sprawl is working its way towards the history books. Rather than wasting time beating ourselves up as to “how stupid we were”, we need to look forward, not backward. We need to figure out how to wisely use what we have to transition to the next lifestyles, the next economy. To get there, we need oil, gas and coal. So take a roughneck or a coal miner to lunch!
So, you ride a bike or walk? Sure, you use far less energy. But the bike is made of coal (smelted aluminum and iron) and oil (tires, seat, plastic), then it is painted with oil. It’s a Gary Fisher, you say? OK, clear-coated with oil, or anodized with coal. Your Nikes or Chacos are pure oil, plus some coal (Chinese electricity) toted over on a smoky, Bunker No. 6-burning container ship. Your PV system (and mine): oil (plastic) and coal (aluminum), in combination with coal (electricity to make the smelt the silicon, refine the cadmium and tellurium), plus some more coal (electricity) to run the plant. And those coal plants which make the electricity to make these “clean energy” solar cells (of yours and mine) are over in China, where they can’t be protested. They’re out of sight and out of mind, unless you’re Chinese and breathing the effluent of a plant which no doubt has far fewer scrubbers and precipitators than those required in the US.
The point is, currently and for the foreseeable future, we are all dependent on these extractive industries, and fossil fuels. So we all need to work together - and not demonize industries that we need - even as we transition to lifestyles with far lower energy usage and local energy production using alternatives.
On the Hirsh Report
I have been a follower of the Hirsch Report since 2004-2005 when it was located exclusively on the “Hilltop Lancers” high school website (I think I found it there due to the Energy Bulletin). I have been familiar with Hubbert’s Peak and a student of oil supply since the mid-1980’s. Even so, when I read the Hirsch Report for the first time - saw who wrote it, who commissioned it - it really sent a chill up my spine. I have had the pleasure of hearing Dr. Hirsch on several occasions – both times at ASPO-USA conferences – in Sacramento and Denver. Observing how his report has no doubt affected him, personally – sent another chill up my spine.
In this most recent posting, I paraphrased the time periods stated in the Hirsch Report, for simplicity. Frankly, yesterday’s gone, and it’s what we do today and tomorrow that counts. None of us knows the timing exactly. We do know that we best “get going”. Recently I have tried to “tone it down” a bit: I think the “imminent crisis” theme turns off certain groups of folks. Regardless, there are lots of writers already making the “crisis case”, so it would seem that another approach might reach incremental people. Namely, it’s easy, fun and fashionable to use less oil, and less energy in general. Anyway, a long-winded explanation for why I simplified the Hirsch Report conclusions.
For the record, I have published the Hirsch Report conclusions in detail, previously, in “The coming liquid fuels crisis: The natural gas (partial) solution”, as excerpted here:
Many of us in the "Peak Oil community" believe that in 2008, the worldwide rate of oil production likely reached a level which, for all practical purposes, will never again be exceeded. In other words, we believe Peak Oil likely occurred in 2008. Dr. Hirsch, in the 2005 report he co-authored for the Department of Energy, said the following:On Collapse
Perhaps we could say that some of the actions taken over the last several years - due to oil price signals - would count for a year or two of preparation; essentially, though, we are set up for Dr. Hirsch's "severe consequences" scenario.
- "Initiating a mitigation crash program 20 years before peaking appears to offer the possibility of avoiding a world liquid fuels shortfall for the forecast period."
- "Initiating a mitigation crash program 10 years before world oil peaking helps considerably but still leaves a liquid fuels shortfall roughly a decade after the time that oil would have peaked."
- "Waiting until world oil production peaks before taking crash program action leaves the world with a significant fuel deficit for more than two decades." (emphasis added) Additionally, he went on to say, "Late initiation of mitigation may result in severe consequences."
I am against it. I have read all the books and blogs, from Jared Diamond to the Olduvai Theory to Jay Hanson, and on. The Rainwater Prophecy is linked on the blog. But so long as we are not yet “collapsed”, there is the potential for the great ingenuity of the people of our country and the world to ultimately prevail. I won’t give up hope or effort, and I trust that a lot of others won’t, either. I’m just not a fatalist; I believe we can make a difference. That doesn’t mean, of course, that we won’t have “severe consequences” to deal with.
The reality is - although there is a long ways to go, there is also “a lot going on”, much of it over the last five years. None of these steps, taken alone, will “save the world”. Symbolically, however, they represent changes in behavior and belief that if continued and extended, will have meaningful effects:
- Vegetable gardening – interest has blossomed in the last few years (just ask the folks in the garden department of Home Depot).
- Local food movement – on fire in various cities, all over the country; Farmer’s Markets are popping up everywhere.
- Grassfed beef, pastured poultry, pork – healthier, less energy intensive; can provide scalable starting places for new family farms.
- Backyard chicken movement – growing everywhere, it seems; keeping chickens is “cool”, now.
- Vehicle choices – change is ongoing; there are fewer trucks and large SUV's, more small cars.
- Reusable grocery bags – a small but important and symbolic step; usage is trending upwards.
- Smaller, more efficient houses – witness the plethora of news coverage and books about smaller or “tiny” houses; the McMansion is no longer cool.
- Small energy production – innovators continue to advance small wind, PV, solar thermal, woodgas, alcohol, algae, biodiesel, and more.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Editorial Notes ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
UPDATED (July 17): Added full text of Jan's comments at at the beginning. -BA
Martin Payne is an Energy Bulletin contributor.
Mr. Payne is an "upstream oil and gas professional with over 25 years of experience. Past Chairman, Houston Chapter of the American Petroleum Institute (API). Member of American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME), Society of Petroleum Engineers (SPE), American Solar Energy Society (ASES)."
His blog is Peak Opportunities.
-BA
Martin Payne is an Energy Bulletin contributor.
Mr. Payne is an "upstream oil and gas professional with over 25 years of experience. Past Chairman, Houston Chapter of the American Petroleum Institute (API). Member of American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME), Society of Petroleum Engineers (SPE), American Solar Energy Society (ASES)."
His blog is Peak Opportunities.
-BA
Saturday, July 3, 2010
BP - Macondo Incident Summary & Data: Congressional Committee on Energy and Commerce Link
From the link shown below, choose the "Letter to Tony Hayward" link for the results of the Congressional investigation, and a good summary of the causes of the Macondo incident:
http://www.energycommerce.house.gov/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=2043:chairmen-send-letter-to-bp-ceo-prior-to-hearing&catid=122:media-advisories&Itemid=55
http://www.energycommerce.house.gov/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=2043:chairmen-send-letter-to-bp-ceo-prior-to-hearing&catid=122:media-advisories&Itemid=55
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
A parachute might be an analogy for a blowout preventer. Although you function test both and check them regularly, you don't want to get yourself into an emergency situation where you have to use them. That is "Job One" you might say, namely staying out of that situation. Further, if you have to use them, you need to use them early. Waiting, and attempting to close a well flowing at a high rate could be likened to trying to open your parachute at 100 feet.
So, what are the tanks, troops and artillery in drilling and completing a well? There are many, and in drilling a well, you can "pull the plug on the war" at any time if you are prepared and do it soon enough. Among other things, you design your casing/hole size such that there is enough cement sheath to create effective cement isolation, which also requires the proper cement slurry and centralizing the casing in the hole. Then after the cement job - on a difficult, high pressure well - you stay "on guard" for "gas flow after cementing", ie when gas flows in due to the setting of the cement's removal of hydrostatic pressure - before the cement has set enough to contain it. Then you test your liner top, and you take action to fix any problem. Then you make good decisions about displacing the pressure controlling mud out of the well. Then if you decide to do that, you make sure you have a way to keep track of the mud coming out, versus the seawater going in, to make sure that the well is not "coming in". If the well starts to come in, or flow, you close the blowout preventer immediately and begin circulating the mud back in, then fix the problem that allowed the well to flow. You don't wait until oil and gas are seen at the surface to shut the well in; by that time, it may be too late - you're opening your parachute at 100'. Finally, and most importantly, you have a highly experienced, sufficiently rested person (one person) in charge at all times. All of the above are "standard operating procedures" in any well control manual. These procedures were developed beginning, say, in the 1950's. (The above is just an example, and it is only coincidental if it resembles some of what might have occurred on the Macondo well.)