Tuesday, October 7, 2008

Fix energy, fix the economy

Recently there has been much discussion as to the outlook for oil and gas prices, given the credit crisis. Hundreds of millions have been invested in new drilling rigs, leases, personnel and other infrastructure. The concern in the oilpatch is that the increased shale gas deliverability and the credit crisis-induced demand destruction may create a sharp, disruptive, price decline. At the same time, Fortune recently published Matt Simmons' "$500 per barrel" article.

So, what's the answer? Is it going to be $50 oil, or $500 oil? As usual, there is no simple answer. There's just a lot going on. The following is an attempt to lay out some of the key factors.

Overarching theme: As previously published (and as paraphrased from the wise words of Tom Whipple of ASPO-USA), "Worldwide oil depletion is in a race with demand destruction." Curent oil prices would indicate that the credit crisis-induced demand destruction is currently winning. The recently published EIA demand data shows a 6.4% drop in July 2008 demand, versus that of July 2007.

What could affect/interrupt demand destruction over the next few years?

  • some sort of military event, which you can probably imagine, which could close the Straits of Hormuz or damage other key chokepoints or installations. This scenario is likely the only one (save hyperinflation) which could deliver Matt Simmons' $500 pricing, over the next few years.
  • Venezuela, Nigeria and Mexico are the 3rd, 4th and 5th largest suppliers of crude oil to the US. In late September, Chavez was in talks with the Chinese to ramp up exports from a current 250,000 BO/D to 1 MMBO/D by 2012. The US currently imports about 1.2 MMBO/D from Venezuela, so presumably the Chinese increase would come at the expense of the US. Meanwhile, Nigeria appears about to blow, literally, at any time. And Mexico is reeling from "Peak Oil Posterchild", Cantarell, which has recently declined 30 % year-over-year. My guess is that Mexico will have to cease all exports by about 2010!
  • the BTC pipeline in/near Georgia is scheduled to transport some 840,000 BO/D for the rest of 2008, then 1 MMBO/D in 2009. Obviously, it is subject to further Russian mischief. This oil primarily supplies the EU.
  • the "groupthink" at the recently held ASPO-USA conference seems to have been that natural gas may be in short supply within the next few years. Two reasons. First, it seems that due to the delay/retraction of proposed coal plants (due to all the protests), utilities are being forced to "pencil in" simple, combined cycle natural gas plants as their near term solution to meeting demand. Andy Weissmann and others believe that they all may be counting on the same gas, which may not be there. Secondly, others believe that production from shale gas is not sustainable in the near term. (This author believes that shale gas as well as other unconventional and conventional natural gas sources can, in fact, supply enough gas for incremental power generation as well as for the replacement of some portion of gasoline and diesel fuels in vehicles - over, say, a 10 to 20 year term.) Also realize that other groups believe that there may be a near term glut of natural gas, due to substantial shale gas drilling and new LNG landings.
In summary, it appears that demand destruction may mask the reality of Peak Oil for a time, perhaps for a few years. This "stay of execution" is an important opportunity that should not be wasted. Namely, the next 24 months should be utilized to rapidly implement:

  • energy conservation (this is where we can have the greatest effect, the soonest)
  • mass transportation retrofits (likely optimized and marketed bus and carpool efforts)
  • natural gas vehicles and stations (start with fleets to solve the Catch-22)
  • expanded natural gas drilling (solve infrastructure & supply problems)
  • wind energy (stop the tax credit hocus pocus - fix it for a reasonable time period)
  • vehicular electrical storage research (cost effective and reliable batteries or other devices)
  • design & production of more efficient cars (lighter, smaller EV's, plug-in hybrids and diesels)
  • offshore drilling (offshore West Coast, East Coast, Florida Coast)
  • biofuels research (enzyme & pyrolysis-based cellulosic ethanol, algae-based oil production)
  • nuclear plants (fast-track & standardize the design, licensing and construction, use breeders and reprocessing to minimize waste)
  • coal plants (use best available, cost-effective clean up technology)
  • solar thermal innovations & implementations
  • geothermal and waste heat recovery installations
The good news? It appears that both Presidential candidates agree on most of the above; in fact, one group refers to their energy solution as the "all of the above" solution.

Furthermore, at least one group has advanced, albeit not very articulately, that "energy is the solution to the economy".

What is meant by this?

Well, despite my personal aversion to additional government involvement, the fact of the matter is that we face both an economic abyss, and an energy abyss. Time is short, both for the economy and for oil. Rather than spending a trillion dollars on buying toxic derivatives, or on a war, these funds would be better spent in helping private enterprise jump-start the above referenced conservation techniques and alternate energy research and implementation. The use of our hard-earned tax dollars to help accelerate these initiatives would create jobs and new businesses. The bottom-line is that solving the energy problem - which must be dealt with anyway, and soon - is the perfect solution to solving the consumption- and credit-induced economic dislocation we are now beginning to experience. There would be a third, important benefit. Energy conservation, increased natural gas use and alternate energy implementation all help lower CO2 emissions.

Sunday, August 31, 2008

Putting Cantarell's continued decline into perspective

PEMEX recently announced that Cantarell Field produced just 1,010,000 barrels of oil per day in July, versus 1,050,000 barrels per day in June. That's a drop of 40,000 barrels per day, in just one month. Now, an oilfield's production does fluctuate month-to-month, but to put this into perspective, a loss of 40,000 barrels per day is equal to 30% of the estimated peak production rate from Shell's Perdido project, which is being constructed in 8000' of water near the international boundary with Mexico!

The Perdido project (http://www.shell.com/home/content/aboutshell/our_strategy/major_projects_2/perdido/perdido_13032008.html) is a multi-billion dollar, multi-year project using state-of-the-art technology. Yet the world's second largest oilfield is capable of dropping 30% of the ultimate, maximum rate of this project - in just one month!

What will we do when Mexico, the 5th (was 4th) largest exporter of oil to the U.S., has no more oil for us? Good question. Unfortunately, we'll find out the answer before long.

This is what Peak Oil is all about. World-wide, there are many oil and gas projects that need to be pursued. But they just can't keep up with the depletion from the "Giant" oilfields that we've unconsciously relied upon for years!

So, what do we need to be doing? We need to increase the rate of implementation of the following efforts:

  • energy conservation (this is where we can have the greatest effect, the soonest)
  • mass transportation retrofits (likely optimized and marketed bus and carpool efforts)
  • natural gas vehicles and stations (start with fleets to solve the Catch-22)
  • expanded natural gas drilling (solve infrastructure & supply problems)
  • wind energy (stop the tax credit hocus pocus - fix it for a reasonable time period)
  • vehicular electrical storage research (cost effective and reliable batteries or other devices)
  • design & production of more efficient cars (lighter, smaller EV's, plug-in hybrids and diesels)
  • offshore drilling (offshore West Coast, East Coast, Florida Coast)
  • biofuels research (enzyme & pyrolysis-based cellulosic ethanol, algae-based oil production)
  • nuclear plants (fast-track & standardize the design, licensing and construction)
  • coal plants (use best available, cost-effective clean up technology)
  • solar thermal innovations & implementations

Oil Prices Versus Contracting Economies

Here is something to keep in mind as you try to make sense of what is going on in the world, in terms of geopolitics, oil prices and macroeconomics:

"There is a world wide race going to between contracting economies and world oil production, the score of which will be kept in the price of oil."

Tom Whipple, 8/28/08

Tom Whipple is the editor of the Falls Church News-Press, in Falls Church, Virginia

Whipple goes on to say that a wildcard could exist in terms of OPEC's willingness to accept less than "X" dollars for a barrel of oil. In other words, if and when demand destruction and economic contraction drop overall demand and thus the price for oil, OPEC could once again begin restricting production to increase prices.

In summary, a short term drop in oil prices (6 months? 2 years?) does not mean that the effects of worldwide giant oilfield depletion (aka Peak Oil) are over, only that other macroeconomic events have taken precedence, for a bit. Let's hope that the efforts being slowly set in motion (conservation, mass transportation retrofits, natural gas vehicles, expanded natural gas drilling, wind energy, battery/electrical storage research, design/production of more efficient cars, offshore drilling, biofuels research, nuclear plants, coal plants, solar thermal innovations) are not slowed as we enter a possible "eye" of the Peak Oil hurricane.


Thursday, August 7, 2008

Mexican Production/Cantarell Update

From Oil & Gas Journal, July 28, 2008:
  • Total Mexican production, June 2008: 2.9 MMBO/D
  • June 2007: 3.21 MMBO/D
  • Average, first 6 months of 2008: 2.86 MMBO/D, decline of 9.7% from year earlier
  • Cantarell production, June 2008: 1.05 MMBO/D (MP note: See the February 2008 post on this blog - included is a production schedule which was "reverse engineered" from Pemex's statements at that time. Based on this Feb 2008 schedule, the rate wouldn't be down to 1.05 MMBO/D until the end of 2009. And, if declines continue as they are, production may well finish 2008 at the rates projected for the end of 2010! And this projection was done only 6 months ago. This is indicative of the overwhelming and surprisingly large declines experienced late in the "life" of a depletion drive oil field.)
  • "producing more gas at Cantarell, where gas is moving into wells that formerly produced oil" (MP note: not good in an oil field)

Saturday, June 21, 2008

Update on Mexican Production, Exports

The May 5, 2008 issue of the Oil & Gas Journal included the following articles:

Mexico imports more gasoline as oil production drops
  • Gasoline imports rose to 367,000 bbls per day in March 2008 (6.5 % increase from February).
  • Oil production declined in the first quarter of 2008 to 2.91 MMBO/D.
  • And this shocker: "Mexico's premier Cantarell field produced 1.15 MMBO/D in March 2008 ..." Note that this is below the year end rate we projected in our last post, shown below.
Mexico to reduce oil exports to US in 2008

(Didn't take long for our March "prophecy" to be manifest.)

  • "Mexico will reduce its crude exports to the US by an average of 184,000 BO/D throughout 2008, a situation that could continue for 2 years longer ..." The latter, quite an understatement!
  • "... original plan for exports in 2008 envisioned some 1.678 MMBO/D ..."
  • "... US EIA earlier this month predicted a 13.2 % shortfall of imports from Mexico during the current fiscal year. According to EIA figures, Mexico exported 1.533 MMBO/D to the US in 2007."
  • "Based on its December 2007 Short-Term Energy Outlook, EIA forecast Mexico would produce 3.52 MMBO/D in 2007 and 3.32 MMBO/D in 2008." It looks like the EIA's forecast for 2008, done in December 2007, is off by some 410,000 BO/D - for the first quarter of 2008! You'd think they could get a little closer than that!
To refresh your memory, Mexico nationalized oil in 1938. A Constitutional provision was created that prohibited ownership of oil and gas reserves by anyone other than the Mexican government. Mexico and Mexicans take great pride in their nationalism regarding their oil resources. Pemex is the national oil company which are operates Mexico's oil and gas projects.

Unfortunately, some of Mexico's largest remaining reserves likely exist in a "deepwater" (water depths greater than 1300') area in the Gulf of Mexico. And despite the fact that Pemex employs some very intelligent folks, they don't have the years of experience in research, development, engineering and construction of deepwater drilling and production projects.

Previously, it was believed that Pemex could rely on the world's largest, most capable service companies - Schlumberger and Halliburton - in order to provide everything needed for deepwater exploration and production. However, Schlumberger and Halliburton cannot even do this. Deepwater exploration and production is the realm of Shell Offshore, ExxonMobil, ChevronTexaco, BP and just a few others. To give one an idea of what is required, a deepwater project can cost several billion dollars, and each well can cost $20 - $50 million. And ExxonMobil invests $200 million dollars per year in just researching deepwater technologies.

Now, none of the the companies listed above desire to risk billions of dollars if they don't get a share of the oil and gas that might be found. Their shareholders insist on this! But the current Mexican Constitution won't allow it. Talks have been held, followed by intense protests, led by the former mayor of Mexico City and defeated Presidential candidate, Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador. It doesn't look good for the development of Mexican deepwater areas - but anything could happen.

On the other hand, to give you an idea of the scope of the problem with the dwindling giant oilfields like Cantarell, take a look at Shell's Perdido project, which was in the news in early June. Perdido will be anchored not far from Mexican deepwater areas, in 8000' of water. It is costing billions, has taken years to construct and when in place, it will produce 130,000 barrels of oil per day.

That is about one-third of what Cantarell LOST in only 3 months, from December 2007 through March 2008! Getting the picture about Peak Oil?




Wednesday, March 19, 2008

Mexican Oil Exports: Start Saying Adios!


Most folks are surprised to learn that the world’s second largest oil field is not located in Saudi Arabia. Nor even in the Middle East. In fact, it is located offshore Mexico, in the Bay of Campeche, Gulf of Mexico. This “giant” field, with an ultimate recovery which may reach 20 billion barrels, was discovered in 1976 by Rudesindo Cantarell. Sr. Cantarell was not a geologist, nor a geophysicist, but rather ... a fisherman. It seems that the natural oil seeps were playing havoc with his nets! PEMEX, the national oil company of Mexico, finally investigated it and the rest, as they say, is history.

Cantarell Field, as it turns out, is a real freak of geology. The porosity - or holes in the rock where the oil is located - is believed to be the result of a rubble pile from an asteroid strike which took place some 65 million years ago! And not just any asteroid strike: The asteroid which caused what has become known as the Chicxulub Crater, on the Yucatan Peninsula, is thought to have been 6 miles in diameter, and many scientists attribute this particular asteroid strike as being the “extinction event” that took out the dinosaurs! The impact energy from that strike is believed to have been some 2 million times that of the largest man-made explosion, that of the Tsar Bomba, a 50 megaton hydrogen device set off by Russia in 1961. Interesting stuff!

Cantarell was put on production in 1979. Production was 1.16 million barrels per day (1.16 MMBO/D) in 1981, and in 1995 production was still 1 MMBO/D. In 2000, PEMEX installed the world’s largest nitrogen injection project on Cantarell. In this process, nitrogen is stripped from air and injected into the upper parts of the reservoir in order to maintain reservoir pressure, and thus to increase or maintain production. Production increased to 1.6 MMBO/D in 2001, then to 1.9 MMBO/D in 2002, and then to 2.1 MMBO/D in 2003. By the end of 2005, however, production had returned to 1.9 MMBO/D. In January, 2006, a PEMEX press release unveiled their conclusion that Cantarell had peaked, and would decline down to a rate between 1.5 MMBO/D and 0.5 MMBO/D by the end of 2008. The attentive folks at the Wall Street Journal must have sensed the significance of this event, as they first ran this story on 2/9/06, and they published an update in August of 2006. Since this time it appears they have been revisiting the story about every February, with stories on 1/27/07, and most recently on 2/15/08.

As of the end of 2007, Cantarell was said to be producing 1.4 MMBO/D, or down some 600,000 BO/D (or 29 %) from its peak rate in 2004!

Why is this important? Well, Mexico is the 3rd largest exporter of oil to the United States. Out of about 20 MMBO/D of total consumption (maybe closer to 21 MMBO/D now), we import some 60 %, or around 12 MMBO/D. Mexico makes up some 1.4 MMBO/D of that 12 MMBO/D, or about 10 % of our total imports.

So, if Mexico can’t supply that oil - just get it somewhere else, right? Well it appears that there is little or no “spare” capacity in oil production RATE, worldwide. So, if we need 1.4 MMBO/D from Mexico but they can’t supply it, we either have to get that oil instead of someone else, or do without. The oil pricing or geopolitical implications of this scenario should speak for themselves.

To put the ultimate loss of 1.5 MMBO/D out of Cantarell into perspective, consider the massive tar sands in Canada. Even though these tar sand RESERVES are huge, their production RATE is limited by the QUALITY of these deposits. Namely, one has to shovel, melt or dissolve this tar out of the ground. Today’s total production RATE from these tar sands, after huge efforts and investments of billions of dollars, only totals about 1.1 MMBO/D. And, with billions more invested, by 2015 they believe the rate can be increased by an additional 1.9 MMBO/D. So, if there weren’t any other RATE declines going on around the world, and if demand was not increasing, then the Canadian tar sands might be able to compensate for the loss of Cantarell.

Put another way, if other declines ARE present around the world, and if there are not many provinces where the RATE is significantly increasing (such as with the Canadian tar sands), and if the increases from the tar sands can barely make up for Cantarell declines, then what significant capacity increases are available to make up for the other declines?

So, Cantarell Field is a "poster child" for Peak Oil concerns.

Most recently we wondered, “If Cantarell is down significantly, and other Mexican production is up some, but not enough to compensate, what must be making up the balance?” Namely, if production is down and Mexican domestic consumption is flat or up (as is normal in a developing country), then imports must go up, or exports must go down, in order to compensate. In other words, something’s got to give.

After a little investigation, we were troubled by the conclusions.

First, using a decline profile we derived from the Oil and Gas Journal/El Financero/Sener data, we projected Cantarell to be down to 1.204 MMBO/D by the end of 2008.

Next, we arrived at the projected 2008 oil production by adjusting the 2007 figure of 2.925 MMBO/D (average of 11/2007 & 12/2007, from Reuter’s, 1/21/08, UPDATE 3-Mexico oil output, exports wane in 2007) for the projected 2008 Cantarell decline. (In doing so, we are assuming little if any increase in production from other Mexican fields for 2008. Since 2004, those other fields have only been able to increase production and make up for about 100,000 BO/D of the 600,000 BO/D drop in Cantarell production.)

We are still using the Mexican oil import number (that is, imports of oil into Mexico) of 309,000 BO/D, from the world factbook estimate from 2004. It seems likely that imports of oil into Mexico over that period have dropped, as imports elsewhere typically have done.

Additionally, for 2008 we use the Mexican domestic consumption figure of 2.078 MMBO/D (also from the 2004 world factbook estimate). This seems too conservative, and unlikely. Namely, oil consumption increased in most developing countries over the 2004 – 2008 timeframe.

As to exports, the world factbook shows 2.268 MMBO/D was exported from Mexico in 2004. And the Reuter’s article lists 1.684 MMBO/D as the amount exported on an average basis, in 2007. That’s a drop of 584,000 BO/D, from 2004 though 2007! Where was this oil going, and what are those folks doing to replace about 600,000 BO/D over that interval?

In summary, the projected 2008 Mexican oil balance of -730,000 BO/D doesn’t appear to be too far out of line with past “balances” shown by our rough calculations, but the concerns are:

  • One would think that consumption in Mexico would be up, over the last 4 years.
  • It is unlikely Mexico is still importing as much oil as in 2004.
  • Exports show to be down 26 % since 2004! This is a significant trend!
  • The “balance item” is substantial enough in relation to US imports of Mexican oil that it could materially impact that US import figure.

Once again - conservation, alternative energy efforts and domestic exploration all must be significantly increased as it appears that the days are numbered as to getting a significant amount of oil from Mexico. More specific recommendations to follow in the next report.

Footnotes for chart:

  1. Prior to 2005, Cantarell produced at a flat rate of 2 MMBO/D for a short period of time. During this time the field was being injected with huge volumes of nitrogen for pressure maintenance.
  2. Mexican oil production has been widely quoted as 3.4 MMBO/D in 2004 – 2005, same figure also recently used in a Wall Street Journal (2-15-08) article.
  3. The Sener study, referenced in the recent El Financero newspaper article, in turn quoted by Oil and Gas Journal (2-7-08), listed specific declines for Cantarell for 2005, 2006, 2007.
  4. Cantarell 2008 ending rate based on the production projection derived based on decline rates quoted in El Financero article.
  5. Declines from Cantarell applied to total, initial rate in 2005, so we are assuming the other production in Mexico remains flat.
  6. same
  7. Imports from world factbook page, assumed flat.
  8. Exports from world factbook page, assumed flat until new data for 2007.
  9. Consumption from world factbook page, assumed flat. But usually consumption increases over time.
  10. Balance should be zero, represents errors in one or more estimates.
  11. Imports from Mexico into the US, from EIA page.
  12. Same as (11), but average for 11 months in 2007.
  13. From Reuter’s (1/21/08), “UPDATE 3 – Mexico oil output, exports wane in 2007”.




Sunday, March 9, 2008

US Oil Imports, By Country



Although easily found on the Energy Information Administration's (EIA's) website, here for convenience are the monthly volumes of oil imported into the US from the top 20 suppliers, sorted from greatest to lowest monthly volume. We have also calculated the average daily rate of oil imported in December 2007, as well as each country's percentage of the total US imports during that month.

Note that in December 2007, Mexico fell behind Venezula and became the 4th largest exporter of oil to the US, rather than the 3rd largest. Watch the next post for more details.

Remember, the US imports about 60 % of the liquid hydrocarbons/petroleum that it consumes.